Updated February 9, 1999, 4:08 p.m. ET
Lawyer with ties to white supremacist group fights for license
EAST PEORIA, Ill. (AP) In three years of law school, Matt Hale
made decent grades, participated in student groups and played
violin in two orchestras. He also helped revive a white supremacist
group that advocates a racial holy war.
Hale graduated last May, passed the bar exam and was hired by an
Illinois law firm. But he never got his law license, snubbed by a
state committee that reviews the "character and fitness" of
prospective attorneys.
The panel, comprised of two lawyers and a judge, cited his
racist leanings.
Hale is "free ... to incite as much racial hatred as he desires
and to attempt to carry out his life's mission of depriving those
he dislikes of their legal rights," panel members wrote in their
2-1 opinion in December.
"But in our view he cannot do this as an officer of the
court."
Miffed by the vote all but 25 of more than 3,000 applicants
last year were approved Hale has appealed to a separate state
committee that could overturn the decision.
"The idea that I can't be lawyer because of my views is
ludicrous," he said, sitting in a home office where an Israeli
flag serves as a doormat, swastika stickers decorate the walls and
the flag of Hale's group, the World Church of the Creator, hangs
from a window. He is 27.
Hale's effort to gain a law license has attracted some unlikely
supporters, including the Anti-Defamation League and renowned
attorney Alan Dershowitz, who said he may help in Hale's appeal.
"Character committees should not become thought police,"
Dershowitz said. "It's not the content of the thoughts I'm
defending, it's the freedom of everybody to express their views and
to become lawyers."
As a boy in East Peoria, Hale immersed himself in books about
Nazis and formed a "Little Reich" group at school. In high school
and at Bradley University he attended "white power" rallies and
sent letters filled with racial slurs to newspapers.
He also had brushes with the law, including a citation for
littering after trying to distribute racist newspapers to homes. He
was elected head of the World Church of the Creator while attending
Southern Illinois University law school.
The church, founded in 1973 in Florida, espouses a racial holy
war against Jews and blacks. One group member is serving a life
sentence for killing a black sailor in Florida in 1991.
The church, which foundered for a few years, has thrived under
Hale's leadership, according to the ADL. Hale's claim of as many as
30,000 supporters could not be verified.
Illinois officials say the last case similar to Hale's was in
the early 1950s, when a law student refused to take an
anti-Communist loyalty oath.
The U.S. Supreme Court last considered a similar case in 1971,
when two applicants for law licenses in other states would not
reveal their political beliefs. The court ruled in their favor.
The ADL believes Hale shouldn't be denied a law license because
of the "slippery slope" it creates, said Andrew Shoenthal,
assistant director in the group's Chicago office.
For instance, Shoenthal asked, could a prospective lawyer who
opposes abortion or supports school prayer be denied a license if a
majority in his community held an opposite view?
The Illinois State Bar Association has yet to take a position on
Hale's case, but spokesman Dave Anderson said the case "is a hot
topic (among lawyers) right now, with spirited debate on both
sides."
Hale, meanwhile, was fired by the law firm because he couldn't
obtain the license. He lives with his parents in East Peoria, with
an office in their home.
He is optimistic he'll get his license and plans to open a solo
practice. He hopes to challenge affirmative action laws and the
littering law for which he was cited.
"For me, the true test of character is whether a person says
what they think, which is what I have always done," Hale said. "I
believe I show more character than most attorneys in that I
actually practice what I preach."
|