Updated December 12, 2000, 6:15 p.m. ET
Florida Supreme Court rules in absentee ballot case  
   

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (AP) — In twin victories for George W. Bush, the Florida Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that 25,000 absentee ballots challenged in two Florida counties should count in the state's contested presidential election.

In a pair of 6-0 opinions, the justices upheld the rulings of two state judges, both of whom had said the ballots should count even though local election officials permitted Republican activists to add information to the ballot applications.

The effect of the rulings was to validate votes which — if discarded — could have let Al Gore overtake Bush in the state that stands to pick the next president.

The court's ruling also cleared away the last significant challenges the Democrats have short of the pivotal case before the U.S. Supreme Court. There, the justices toiled to fashion a ruling on Gore's bid to resume manual recounts of thousands of questionable ballots.

In the Seminole County case, where more than 15,000 absentee ballots were challenged, the court said it found "competent, substantial evidence to support the trial court's conclusion that the evidence in this case does not support a finding of fraud, gross negligence or intentional wrongdoing in connection with any absentee ballots."

The court did agree that Seminole's elections supervisor erred by rejecting completely the absentee ballot applications in question and then compounded the problem by letting Republicans correct omissions on the forms.

"The court does not in any sense condone the irregularities found by the trial court," Florida Supreme Court spokesman Craig Waters said, reading from a statement on the steps of the high court.

Waters added that in the Martin County case, in which 10,000 absentee ballots were challenged, there were also irregularities, but they, too, did not reach "the level of fraud or intentional misconduct."

Justice Leander J. Shaw Jr. recused himself from both rulings for reasons that Waters did not specify.

Bush attorney Barry Richard welcomed the decisions. "It clearly ends it — no place to go from here," he said.

Gore spokesman Doug Hattaway tried to put a positive spin on the result, saying that resolution of the case removes some ammunition the Bush camp has used against Gore as it pushes the Florida Legislature to pass a resolution making sure the state's 25 electoral votes were pledged to Bush.

"The Bush supporters in the Legislature were using these cases as a fig leaf to cover their attempt to overturn the results of the election. That fig leaf has now been stripped away," he said.

Democrats had sought to throw out 25,000 votes in the two counties, alleging that Republicans were unfairly permitted to correct ballot applications while Democrats were not given the same opportunity.

But two Leon County Circuit Court judges refused, finding that election officials did not intentionally seek to help one political party rather than another and that the voters should not be punished by having their votes discarded.

Gore, who has insisted that every vote must be counted, was not a party to either lawsuit.

The state Supreme Court ruling came after both sides submitted written arguments Monday.

In the arguments, Democratic lawyers pared back their demands, seeking to disqualify only 673 Bush votes in Martin County, still enough to overturn Bush's lead of fewer than 200 votes. In Seminole County, they still wanted to eliminate 15,000 votes.

"You're always disappointed when you lose a case but there's some solace in the fact that they did find serious irregularities," Edward Stafman, lawyer for Martin County voters, said after the ruling.

Lawyers in yet a third absentee ballot case were hoping the U.S. Supreme Court would hear their appeal in the case of 2,400 overseas ballots that arrived in election offices after Election Day, most of them from military personnel. 0 Bush received 1,575 votes of the contested ballots, compared with 836 for Gore, so throwing them out would boost Gore's total.

The voters claim federal law and the U.S. Constitution require all ballots to be received by the close of the polls on Election Day.

Florida law, however, allows for ballots mailed by Election Day as long as they are received within 10 days of the election.

A federal judge ruled against the voters last week, and a three-judge panel of the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta upheld that ruling.

 

 

Full Coverage, Documents
©2000 Courtroom Television Network LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Terms & Privacy Guidelines

Small Court TV Logo


advertisement