|
Estranged couple handcuffed together
MUSKEGON, Mich. A judge, exasperated by conflicting testimony during a personal protection hearing, ordered an estranged couple handcuffed together until one of them changed their story and told him the truth.
Sabrena and Kirk Smith appeared in front of Muskegon County Judge Gregory Pittman on Jan. 25 and offered contradictory accounts regarding a complaint that Kirk had violated a protection order. The judge eventually became irate and told a courtroom deputy to hold the couple "until one of them decided not to lie to the court," according to Kirk Smith's lawyer Harold Closz III.
The deputy cuffed the couple together and placed them in a holding cell.
About a half-hour later, the couple's lawyers conferred with the judge and Sabrena Smith withdrew her complaint. Outside the courtroom, however, Sabrena said that the complaint was true and she withdrew it to stay out of jail.
Calling the judge's ruling "a first," Closz told Court TV that some criticized Pittman for placing a person who had been allegedly assaulted in such a situation. Pittman said he was seeking the truth and was certain that neither spouse posed a threat to the other. Though Sabrena Smith agreed that she never felt endangered, she plans on filing a grievance against Pittman.
The couple, who have been married for 22 years, are in divorce proceedings.
|