| WITNESSES
FOR THE STATE |
| Rebuttal Case |
| Michelle Wright, mother of Carruth's first child
Testified Carruth made a joke about her getting into a car accident
Said Carruth was a good person who treated her respectfully
On Carruth as a father, said Carruth was hardly around and had never sent Rae Jr. a birthday card until after his incarceration
|
| Amber Turner, Carruth's ex-girlfriend
Testified Carruth threatened to kill her if she didn't abort his baby
Said Carruth talked of having his first child, Rae Jr., and the boy's mother, Michelle Wright, killed to avoid child support
Carruth said he didn't want to have a baby with someone he wasn't going to stay with
|
| Donald Kim, Carruth's former neighbor
Testified Carruth attacked him on his wedding day during an argument over parking
Said cars belonging to Carruth and his guests frequently blocked his driveway
Carruth cursed at him when he asked him to move his car, he said
|
| Major Felicia McAdoo, Jail Commander
Said Sgt. Riddle had a reputation of cozying up to high-profile defendants and talking to them about their cases
Testified that she transferred Riddle to another shift after she saw her escorting Carruth within the jail several times
Said Riddle is sometimes "not truthful"
|
| Kimberly Young, Detention Officer
Said she guarded Carruth in December 1999 when he was on suicide watch
Testified that Sgt. Shirley Riddle came to the cell and spoke privately with Carruth for about 15 to 20 minutes
Told jurors this visit and Riddle's request that she not note it in her log were highly unusual
|
| Case in Chief |
| Dr. James Sullivan, Medical Examiner
Testified Adams died of multiple organ system failure
Said some bullets struck Adams after she "flopped" over on passenger car seat
Told jurors that horizontal spread of bullets indicates shooter moved his hand or that Adams' vehicle moved either forward or backward during shooting
|
| Dr. Michael Thomason, director of trauma services, Carolinas Medical Center
Treated Cherica Adams following the shooting; said Adams suffered from "torrential bleeding"
Said heavy medication would not have affected Adams' memories of the shooting
|
| Mark Post, supervisory special agent for the FBI
Coordinated the surveillance of the Tennessee hotel where Carruth was captured after jumping bail
Questioned Wendy Cole who led him to her 1997 Toyota Camry, where Carruth was hiding in the trunk
Took Carruth into custody after his capture
|
| William McBrayer, crime lab ballistics expert
Tested the 38-special and spent cartridges found on Elm Road
Testified that the gun had rusted, prohibiting a positive idenification when comparing the cartridges to those found at the crime scene
Said 31 live rounds found in a storm drain were "consistent" with both bullets recovered at the crime scene and spent cartridges found in the recovered gun
|
| Officer James Wright, Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department
Testified that he recovered the 38-special revolver found by Tichenor from Nearpass on Feb. 5 and put the weapon in the police property lock-up
Said he took the couple back to Elm Road so they could show exactly where they found the gun
|
| Brian Nearpass, Tichenor's boyfriend
Said that after Tichenor told him about the gun, he went to Elm Road and using gloves, picked the gun up and took it back to his office.
Testified that he called the police the same day to report finding the gun.
|
| Christina Tichenor, found 38-special revolver
Told jurors that she was walking along Elm Road Feb. 5, looking for her hubcap, when she saw a gun on the roadside
Said she did not touch it because she is afraid of guns, but later told boyfriend Bryan Nearpass about it
|
| Tanya Ferguson, friend of Carruth
Said Carruth had access to her phone Nov. 16 when three calls including one to Watkins' motel and one to Kennedy were placed
Testified Carruth told her not to speak to his investigator until after talking to his friend Tenisha Huckleberry, who subsequently spoke with Ferguson about the three calls
Gave a glowing description of Carruth's character and said he appeared completely normal on the night Adams was shot
|
| Dwight Perry, owner of car care business
Testified Carruth brought his vehicle for cleaning Nov. 24, the day after police questioned him
Said Carruth used his office phone to make several calls
Two of the calls were to Watkins' motel and one was to Carruth's agent |
| Susan Artieri, Alltel employee
Testified about Tanya Ferguson's cell phone records
Said that in the early hours of Nov. 16, Ferguson's phone called the Villager Lodge, Michael Kennedy, and Carruth's voice mail
|
| Miles Biggerstaff, manager for Bell South
Testified about a flurry of calls made to Watkins and Kennedy hours before the shooting
Said Carruth had a number listed under the name "Rahim Akbar"
|
| Lynn Skinner, telephone records specialist, AT&T Wireless Services
Testified about calls placed by cells phones belonging to Carruth, Kennedy and Adams
Detailed a flurry of calls between Carruth and Kennedy's phones around the time of the shooting
Also outlined calls made from Kennedy's phone to Michael Patrick, the alleged seller of the murder weapon
|
| Sailesh Patel, owner of Villager Lodge
Gunman Van Brett Watkins lived in his motel for about two months up until the time of the shooting
Testified Watkins identified himself as "William Watkins;" Patel was unaware Watkins was using the name of his deceased brother
Watkins earned part of his rent money by washing the motel's exterior
|
|
Charles Shackleford, ex-boyfriend of Candace Smith
The married ex-NBA player said Smith told him that Carruth actually confessed the crime to her
Though he never met Carruth, heard that Carruth believed Adams was sleeping around; met Cherica Adams on a few occasions
Advised Smith to get a lawyer and paid her legal fees
|
|
Melissa Warren, crime scene technician
Investigated the storm drain near where Kennedy, Watkins, and Abraham parked while waiting for Carruth and Adams
Recovered live ammunition, an ammunition box, and a plastic ammunition tray from the drain.
|
 |
Candace Smith, Carruth's ex-girlfriend
Says while in hospital waiting room Carruth said he was present at shooting and that he wished Adams would die
Claims Carruth asked several times to borrow her car in the hours before Adams was shot
Engaged in an argument with Adams who encountered her on date with Carruth
|
|
Officer Kevin Wallin, Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department
Says Carruth asked "odd" questions as he sat in hospital waiting room
Carruth, not yet named a suspect, asked if he would be taken out in handcuffs
Carruth asked if investigators could tell if a gun was fired from his car
|
 |
Officer Peter Grant, Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department
Adams told him before being taken from the
crime scene that Carruth was responsible
Adams told him Carruth slowed down in front
of her when the drive-by shooting occurred
|
 |
Michael Eugene Kennedy,
co-defendant
Said Carruth arranged the shooting and commissioned
Watkins as the gunman
Claims he was threatened into taking part
in plan and getting the gun
Carruth told him he wanted to avoid paying
child support
|
 |
Melvin Billingslea, acquaintance
of Carruth
Was at Carruth's home right before date
with Adams
Said co-defendants Stanley Abraham and Michael
Kennedy were at Carruth's when he arrived
Said Carruth introduced Adams to him as
"his lady"
|
 |
Jeffrey Moonie, Cherica
Adams' father
Said Carruth's behavior was "odd" following
the shooting
Said Carruth denied any knowledge of the
shooting
Present when Adams was writing her notes
in the hospital
|
 |
Modrey Floyd, cousin
of Cherica Adams
Received a call from Adams minutes before
the shooting
Adams asked him to clean her room because
Rae was coming over unexpectedly
Testified he went to Lamaze class when Carruth
failed to show up
|
 |
Farrell Blalock, lived
in house near shooting scene
Heard flurry of gunshots outside his home
night of the shooting
Went outside near Adams' car when emergency
personnel arrived
Heard Adams tell police that her "boyfriend"
was the culprit and that he was driving
a white Ford Expedition
|
 |
Traci Renee Willard,
nurse at Carolinas Medical Center
Held a clipboard as Adams wrote three
pages of notes detailing the shooting
Read back Adams' notes to her, which stated
"he" blocked her car when the shooter pulled
up alongside
Asked Adams whom she was referring to in
her notes; Adams responded, "Rae."
|
 |
Nicole Michaels, paramedic
Said Adams was alert and calm when paramedics
arrived
Identified photos of Adams' car and the
crime scene
Heard Adams tell police that "Rae," her
baby's father, was responsible for the shooting
|
 |
Steve McAuley, supervisor
for Mecklenburg EMS
Testified about the 911
call Adams placed following the shooting
Identified audio tape of the call before
it was entered into evidence
Said the tape was an accurate recording
of the call
|
 |
Angela Baker, 911 operator
for Mecklenburg EMS
Testified about the 911 call Cherica Adams
placed
Took the initial call and put Adams through
to supervisor Steve McAuley
|