By Harriet Ryan
Court TV
NEW YORK Sean
"Puffy" Combs fired a weapon
during an altercation in a crowded
nightclub, a woman shot in the
face during the incident testified
Monday at the rap mogul's bribery
and gun possession trial.
"I saw his arm coming up with
a black gun," Natania Reuben
told jurors. The 30-year-old
hotel clerk from New Jersey
choked back sobs as she recalled
seeing two muzzle flashes and
then feeling a terrible pain
in her cheek.
"It felt like a flaming hot
sledgehammer hitting me in the
face," she said, her voice shaking.
"Blood just began pouring out
of my face and I looked up to
the sky and said, 'Oh, God,
don't take me, I'm not ready
to go.'"
As she dissolved into tears,
a derisive groan rose from
the back of the court where
Combs' family, publicists and
other supporters were seated.
At the defense table, the music
executive shook his head and
stared intently at a page in
the miniature New Testament
he has carried with him since
the first day of jury selection.
Despite the best efforts of
his lawyers and public relations
staff who made separate
attempts to destroy Reuben's
credibility it was a
damaging day for Combs. Reuben
was the second witness to tell
jurors that the Bad Boy Entertainment
CEO had a gun during a 1999
fracas at a Times Square disco,
Club New York, but unlike the
previous witness, whose account
crumbled under cross-examination,
Reuben stuck to her story.
"Why are you trying to change
my testimony, sir?" she barked
at a lawyer for Combs' co-defendant
and protege, Jamal "Shyne" Barrow,
when the attorney questioned
whether she was certain she
had seen Combs and Barrow fire
weapons.
As far back as pretrial hearings,
the defense was calling Reuben
a fraud and promising to shred
her reputation during cross-examination. But Combs' lawyer
Benjamin Brafman had little
to show for his two-hour grilling
of Reuben. He seized on the
$150 million civil suit she
has pending against Combs and
suggested her testimony was
motivated by money, but Reuben
was unapologetic and never wavered
in her account.
The divorced mother of two
boys said she and several girlfriends
went to the club in the early
hours of Dec. 27, 1999, for the
weekly "Hot Chocolate" party.
After about an hour, she noticed
Combs and his entourage
which included girlfriend Jennifer
Lopez and co-defendants Barrow
and Anthony "Wolf" Jones
barreling through the club toward
the exit. She said they moved
with "machismo" pushing other
patrons out of the way and causing
the entire crowd to sway with
their shoves.
"We were basically trying
to hold our ground," she said.
Near the bar, she testified,
Combs' group encountered another
group, and nasty words were
exchanged. She saw money
apparently thrown at Combs in
a sign of disrespect
falling to the ground. When
she looked up again, she said,
both Barrow and Combs' pulled
weapons. She said she heard
"bam bam" and saw muzzle flashes
four feet apart.
"They both fired," she said.
An instant later, she told
jurors, she felt the bullet's
impact. As the club descended
into chaos, she was knocked
to the ground and trampled,
she said.
"I thought I was going to
bleed to death," she testified.
The jury of seven men and five
women paid close attention as
she described stumbling through
the club, looking for help.
People were reviled by her injury,
she said, and covered their faces
in horror.
A bullet had passed through
her cheek and nose and lodged
in the back of her head at the
base of her spine. She told
jurors that despite several
surgeries, seven bullet fragments
remain in her skull and she
suffers headaches and seizures
because of the injuries.
The tall black woman who goes
by the name Eboné spoke
in a strong, confident voice
and seemed to anticipate Brafman's
lines of questioning before
he could carry them out. When
he asked if anyone was standing
in front of her in the packed
club during the fight, she shot
back, "If somebody was in front
of me, I wouldn't have been
shot. They would've been shot."
The defense had hoped to introduce
evidence about Reuben's appearance
on "The People's Court." Brafman
claimed the show taped
before the shooting and aired
after demonstrated her
"devious mind." Reuben, who
owned a salon in Brooklyn, sued
her landlord for failing to
provide adequate heat and television
Judge Jerry Sheindlin awarded
her $115, the cost of a space
heater. Before the show, Reuben
had a friend pose as a potential
customer who left because
of the lack of heat in the salon.
Another friend taped the scene
and Reuben brought it with her
to the taping of the show. Brafman
argued over prosecutor Matthew
Bogdanos' objections that the
jury should hear that she fabricated
videotape evidence to help her
case.
State Supreme Court Judge
Charles Solomon said he wanted
to mull a decision over lunch,
but Combs' publicists didn't
wait. They handed reporters
exiting the courtroom a tape
of the show and a tip sheet
outlining her alleged bad behavior
on the show.
After lunch, Solomon ruled
the jury wouldn't see the tape
or hear about the allegations.
Television news viewers in the
city, however, were another
matter. Clips of Reuben's appearance
on "The People's Court" rolled
on the evening news.
Despite its difficulties Monday,
the defense is expected to continue
its assaults on Reuben's testimony.
Brafman ticked off a list of
Reuben's friends and acquaintances
and asked if she had ever told
them she did not remember the
shooting. "Absolutely not,"
she said.
Brafman later hinted that
he would call these people and
they would tell another story.
Reuben seemed nonplussed.
"Have a nice day," she said
to Brafman as she left the stand.
|