| WITNESSES
FOR THE STATE |
| Case
in Chief |
|
Jeanne Nakashima, Rudin's friend
Admitted she left a message about a chest on Rudin's answering machine in February 1995
Said the message referred to a china closet, not the type of hump back chest Ron Rudin's body was burned in
|
|
Vicki Drapkin, hotel auditor
Worked with Rudin, who called herself Ann Boatwright, in 1998 and lived at the same YMCA in Phoenix
Said she called police after seeing a profile of the Rudin case on America's Most Wanted
Testified that Rudin told her that her late husband's family was trying to cheat her out of assets
|
|
Chris Mendez, Phoenix police officer
Questioned Rudin in 1998 when she was a fugitive from murder charges
Said she claimed her name was Ann Boatwright and knew nothing of the Rudin case
Testified he did not detain her because he could not immediately track down a photo of Rudin or the warrant for her arrest
|
|
Alexia Conger, prosecution investigator
Said she called Rudin in March 1995 to give her a grand jury notification
Testified that Rudin directed her to serve the papers on her attorney
|
|
Caralynne Rudin, Rudin's second wife
Divorced Rudin because of his drinking in 1976, after 5 years of marriage, but continued a close friendship and business relationship
Said Rudin's use of fictitious buyers was a common way to subdivide property and denied defense suggestions that he was engaged in fraud
Told jurors that Rudin used a handkerchief while shaving
|
|
Karen Carmany Gibbs, Rudin's fourth wife
Married to Rudin from 1985 to 1987
Said he kept handkerchief for dabbing blood in a bathroom drawer
Described Rudin as a verbally abusive alcoholic
|
|
Photo not available
|
Charles Leveque, private investigator
Hired by Ron Rudin's trust to investigate his disappearance and death
Said that as an investigative tool, he told a man who owned a gun shop that the reward for information about Rudin's death was increasing "substantial" and anyone but the shooter could be offered immunity
Said he and Sharon Melton retrieved a box from Rudin's office which contained an eavesdropping device
|
|
Yehuda Sharon, Rudin's companion
Said he rented a van the week Rudin disappeared in order to take a business trip to California
Denied forging a receipt that supports trip as a cover story for helping Rudin dispose of her husband's body
Said Rudin brought him papers to review concerning her husband's assets and burial just a few days after he disappeared
Testified he felt threatened by police detectives after Ron Rudin's corpse was discovered and believed they were trying to set him up
|
|
Tom Wahl, Las Vegas police criminalist
Conducted additional DNA testing on red stains found in Rudin's bedroom and on blood on a handkerchief and bone allegedly belonging to Ron Rudin
Concluded that the stains were blood and came from the same donor as the handkerchief
Said DNA from the bone was consistent with the handkerchief as well
|
|
Richard Brooks, anthropologist
Collected "extremely charred" bone fragments in 1995 from fire pit where Rudin's body was found
Catalogued and stored them and sent a report to investigators
Gave them to Wahl to test for DNA in 2001
|
|
Alan Pederson, ATF inspector
Said Rudin was a licensed gun dealer whose stock was inspected by the ATF about one every two years
Testified that ATF records show Rudin reported the 22-calibre murder weapon missing to inspectors in 1990
Acknowledged that his files do not contain a letter from Rudin formally identifying the gun as stolen
|
|
Torrey Johnson, Las Vegas police criminalist
Said he found red particulates which appeared to be blood on the floor of Ron Rudin's Cadillac and sent them to the lab
Test-fired weapon from lake and conclusively matched the bullets to those that killed Ron Rudin
|
|
Ken Hardy, Las Vegas homicide detective
Took gun from ranger who brought it to the police station and secured it in the property room
Said weapons are "regularly" found in the lake
|
|
James Sanborn, park ranger
Said he was summoned to the lake by Peter Price to get the gun
Described picking it up with an old t-shirt he had in his vehicle and ultimately turning it over to headquarters
Testified the area of the lake where the gun was found is about an hour drive from Nelson's Landing, where Rudin's body was burned
|
|
Peter Price, scuba instructor
Said he found a .22-calibre gun wrapped in bags while diving in Lake Mead in July 1996
Testified that he notified park rangers and handed the gun over to Ranger James Sanborn
|
|
Megan Clement, lab technical director
Tested a handkerchief and the stains from Rudin's bedroom for DNA and gender type at private Lab Corp. laboratory
Said the stains on the boxspring, walls and ceiling were consistent with those on the handkerchief
Testified the stains from the walls, ceiling and handkerchief contained male DNA
|
|
Photo not available
|
Richard Ballman, molecular biologist
Tested a handkerchief and the stains from Rudin's bedroom for DNA at private Cellmark Diagnostic laboratory
Said the stains on the boxspring, walls and ceiling were consistent with those on the handkerchief
Testified spots on the "glamour shot" of Margaret Rudin contained human DNA, but further tests were inconclusive
|
|
Photo not available
|
Michael Perkins, police crime scene analyst
Said he and other analysts spent 11 hours collecting evidence in the Rudin home
Testified that the walls and ceiling at the south end of the master bedroom were speckled with about 15 reddish-brown drops which initial tests indicated might be blood
Said the stains appeared to be blood spatter from multiple gunshots to the head
|
|
Linda Errichetto, director of police lab
Said initial tests showed reddish-brown stains on a "glamour shot" of Rudin and on items in her bedroom might be blood
Described collecting stain samples and sending them to private labs for DNA testing
|
|
Yvette Eddy, former craft store employee
The former employee of Michael's Crafts Store testified that Margaret Rudin brought in a portrait to have glass put into the frame
Testified she noticed a scratch in the portrait which Margaret declined to fix
Said she saw no traces of blood on the portrait
|
|
Scott Hardy, crime scene analyst
Collected soil samples from the burn site
Testified gasoline was used to in the fire
|
|
Sheree Norman, crime scene analyst
Took the stand for a second time
Testified about nails and pieces of charred wood, metal and fabric found near Ron Rudin's charred remains
|
|
John Sias, police officer
Trailed Yehuda Sharon three days after police spotted Sharon with Margaret at an L.A. airport
Observed nothing extraordinary on Sharon's return home
|
|
Gene Marshall, police officer
Took the stand for a second time to talk about the phone calls
|
|
Evelyn Sanchez, Sprint
Testified about calls made from the Rudins' residence
None of the calls are consistent with Margaret's account of the last time she claims to have spoken to Ron
Testified about calls made from the residence to a pay phone shortly after police told her Ron's remains were found
|
|
Barbara Lawrence, Verizon Wireless
Testified about calls made from the Rudins' cell phones.
None of the calls are consistent with Margaret's account of the last time she claims to have spoken to Ron
|
|
Wayne Woshioka, LAPD
Followed Margaret Rudin after she and Sharon crossed the California border.
Observed Rudin and Sharon go to Los Angeles Airport and Sharon leave the airport alone
Testified seeing Rudin and Sharon embrace
|
|
Daniel Ford, crime scene analyst
Trailed Margaret Rudin along with Kallas.
Said Margaret Rudin drove past her house when police were in front to conduct a search
Testified Margaret Rudin met with Yehuda Sharon before the two left by car for California
|
|
Michael Givens, surveillance officer
Trailed Margaret Rudin along with Kallas.
Said Margaret Rudin drove past her house when police were in front to conduct a search
Testified Margaret Rudin met with Yehuda Sharon before the two left by car for California
|
|
David Kallas, police officer
Conducted surveillance of Margaret Rudin following her husband's disappearance
Said Margaret Rudin made several phone calls from pay phones and threw personal items in a nearby dumpster
Testified Margaret Rudin met with Yehuda Sharon before the two left by car for California
|
|
Phillip Ramos, detective
Testified about physical evidence he recovered, including Rudin's discarded mattress, a trunk, a blood-stained portrait and letters.
Said Margaret Rudin seemed cold an uninterested about her husband's whereabouts
Believes Margaret Rudin did not act alone and said her friend, Yehuda Sharon, was not cooperative with the investigation
|
|
Terry Hall, Lovato's mother
Said her son told her about the tasks Rudin assigned
him and the blood-like substances he encountered
Testified that she called police because she was
concerned her son might be framed for Ron Rudin's
murder
Denied that she read media reports about the case
and a $25,000 reward before phoning authorities
|
|
Fred Evaristo, former locksmith
Said Margaret Rudin hired him Dec. 25, 1994, to
pick the locks on three doors in her husband's
realty office
Described Rudin as "a little uptight, perhaps
a little anxious" and said she and a female companion
rifled through desk drawers and file cabinets
after he let them in
|
|
Larry Monk, alarm company employee
Testified that the Rudin home had a "nothin' real
spectacular" security system, which included exterior
and interior sirens and motion detectors
Said the system was not engaged from Dec. 12 to
Dec. 18, 1994
Told jurors that records indicate no consistent
pattern in the way the Rudins used the system,
but that after Dec. 18 it was used more regularly
|
|
Augustine Lovato, handyman
Hired by Margaret Rudin to remove the bedroom
carpet
Said "dark brown particles" were under the carpet
and "reddish-brown" stains were on a portrait
Admitted to having a criminal record
|
|
Dona Cantrell-Robinson, Margaret
Rudin's sister
Testified that Rudin seemed more concerned about
her husband's money than his disappearance
Said she sent a photo of the trunk allegedly used
to dispose of Ron Rudin's body to investigators
but refused to testify at the civil trial over
Ron Rudin's money
Admitted to a rocky relationship with her sister
and to getting paid for a Hard Copy interview
|
|
Marina Flores, Rudins' maid
Testified she commonly saw bloody handkerchiefs
in Ron Rudin's bathroom
Said Margaret Rudin changed the carpet in the
master bedroom after Ron's disappearance but that
she never saw blood stains on the carpet or the
portrait over the bed
Testified Margaret Rudin was a nice lady who cried
when her husband disappeared
|
|
Monty Spoor, crime scene analyst
Examined Rudin's Cadillac which he said had a
thin layer of dirt all over it
Testified that four people were in the car last
Said he found clothing, keys and sunglasses inside
the car which had been locked
|
|
Dave Radcliffe, police officer,
Las Vegas Police Department
Took the call from Blasco
Testified he went to the Crazy Horse Too Gentlemen's
Club where he recovered the Cadillac
|
|
Michael Blasco, police officer,
Las Vegas Police Department
Testified he was off-duty when his father called
him about spotting Ron Rudin's black Cadillac
outside Crazy Horse Too
Reported the Dec. 22, 1994, discovery of the car
outside Crazy Horse Too to police
|
|
Patrick Barry, detective,
missing persons unit of the Las Vegas Police Department
Conducted searches and interview with partner
Janise on Dec. 22, 1994
Identified an audio tape of Margaret Rudin's voluntary
statement which was played for the jury
Testified Margaret Rudin told him her marriage
was good lately, that her husband had secretive
business dealings and enemies
|
|
John Epling, acquaintance of
Ron Rudin
Testified the day Rudin was first discovered missing
he looked over a fence at his home at the request
of his mother-in-law, a Rudin employee
Said Rudin's black Cadillac was not there
Said that a light-colored car was parked outside
the house
|
|
Patricia Brown, Ron Rudin's
trust attorney
Told the jury about the creation of Ron Rudin's
trust document and the changes made over the years
Testified about writing the secret directive cutting
anyone responsible for his violent death off from
his money and said it was written specifically
because of Margaret Rudin
Said Ron Rudin told her his marriage was on the
rocks and that Margaret Rudin could be vicious
and violent
|
|
Frank Janise, police officer
in missing person's unit, Las Vegas Police Department
Interviewed Margaret Rudin and searched the Rudin
home on December 22, 1994
Testified he found no sign of foul play
|
|
Iris Meccia, police officer,
Las Vegas Police Department
Took missing person's report from Margaret Rudin.
|
|
Sandra Wassall, police officer,
Las Vegas Police Department
Said Margaret Rudin seemed unconcerned about her
husband's whereabouts
Took statements from Melton and Danner
|
|
Carol Pawazoe, tax specialist
Testified Margaret Rudin came by her office at
2:25 a.m. the first morning Ron Rudin was missing
Said she offered her coffee and claimed to have
been working all night in her neighboring antique
store
Testified Rudin had never come by before
|
|
Holly Quinn, Sharon Melton's
friend
Testified she called Margaret Rudin on the morning
of Dec. 19, 1994
Said she made the call at Sharon Melton's request
Testified that Margaret Rudin was home
|
|
Sharon Melton, Ron Rudin's
bookkeeper
Testified she heard gunshots the day Ron Rudin
disappeared
Said an unconcerned Margaret Rudin seemed to know
her husband was dead before his body was found
Denied knowledge of shady business dealings by
Ron Rudin
|
|
Harold Boscutti, Ron Rudin's
trustee
Said Margaret Rudin acted suspiciously after her
husband first disappeared
Testified about fraudulent business practices
by Ron Rudin
Admitted that acting as trustee yielded him a
portion of Rudin's money
|
|
Sue Lyles, Ron Rudin's mistress
A former employee of Rudin, Lyles admitted to
having an affair with him
Testified about "anonymous" vulgar letters sent
to her children about the affair
Said the day before his disappearance Ron Rudin
was going to confront his wife about the letters
|
|
Dorothia Flint, defendant's
friend
Testified Ron Rudin was home around 8 p.m. on
Dec. 18, the last day he was seen alive.
|
|
Michael Rawlins, civil attorney
Represented Ron Rudin's trust in a probate battle
with Margaret Rudin
Discussed directive by Ron Rudin cutting off anyone
responsible for his violent death
Testified about handwritten phone logs kept by
Margaret Rudin based on conversations she overhead
through listening devices
|
|
Jerrian Munerlyn, Ron Rudin's
office manager
Told jurors about a report Ron Rudin filed about
a missing gun which later became the murder weapon
Testified that Ron Rudin instructed her not to
let Margaret in the office building until he was
gone
|
|
Eugene Marshal, Las Vegas Police
Department
Identified electronic listening devices allegedly
installed by Margaret Rudin in her husband's office
Testified the devices were capable of surreptitiously
monitoring others' conversations
|
|
Richard Aker, Spy Factory employee
Sold Margaret Rudin sophisticated listening devices
Testified she was so upset when one wasn't working
that she called him late at night
Said Margaret Rudin was one of few "regulars"
|
|
Dr. Robert Jordan, coroner
Performed the autopsy on Ron Rudin's charred remains
Testified Rudin died of bullet wounds to the head
Said the bones found near Rudin's skull could
not be positively identified as belonging to Rudin
|
|
David Light, coroner's office
Identified Ron Rudin's skull by analyzing dental
records
|
|
Bruce Honabach, antiques dealer
Testified he sold an antique trunk to Margaret
Rudin which prosecutors believe she used to dispose
of Rudin's body
Said Margaret Rudin complained her husband was
cheap and that she wanted him dead
Told the jury he met Margaret Rudin through Sharon
Melton, Ron Rudin's bookkeeper
|
|
Leslie Peterson, antiques dealer
Testified the trunk at the burn site was consistent
with an antique trunk made in the 1880s
|
|
Sheree Norman, crime scene
analyst
Testified about the charred remains of a trunk
and Ron Rudin's body found at Nelson's Landing
Described the "fire pit" found about 35 feet away
from Rudin's skull
Said an accelerant was detected in the soil
|
|
Russell Dillon
Said he was on a fishing trip with friends at
Nelson's Landing when the group found Rudin's
skull
|
|
Stephen Vermilia
Said he was on a fishing trip with friends at
Nelson's Landing when the group found Rudin's
skull
|