Logo
 
 
 
Updated March 17, 2006, 3:51 p.m. ET

Doctor allegedly wanted lover's husband to 'crush the hands' of business rival
Stephanie Nagel told jurors that Bradley Schwartz asked her to find someone to 'take care' of a rival doctor, who was later slain.

TUCSON, Ariz. — He asked a convicted felon. He asked a man to whom he delivered his urine samples. He even asked a lover to get her husband to do it.

Several witnesses testified Thursday and Friday about how Dr. Bradley Schwartz repeatedly solicited them to hurt or kill Dr. Brian Stidham in the months before his former business partner was murdered.

Stidham's body was found in the parking lot of his medical practice on Oct. 5, 2004. The 37-year-old father of three had been stabbed more than 15 times, and his Lexus was discovered miles away.

Prosecutors say Schwartz, 41, hired Ronald "Bruce" Bigger to kill Stidham and to make the murder look like a carjacking. Phone records and eyewitness accounts link Schwartz and Bigger on the night of the murder, as well as the day after.


Story continues
advertisement

Schwartz's attorneys are expected to argue that police did not fully investigate the slaying and have suggested that a carjacker murdered Stidham.

Aisha Henry told jurors Thursday that Schwartz constantly asked her to help frame Stidham. When she refused to claim that Stidham molested her son, Schwartz came up with another scheme that involved her husband. The fact that Schwartz and Henry were sleeping together at the time didn't seem to faze the doctor, she said.

"He wanted [my husband] to hurt [Stidham], to beat him up and specifically crush his hands to where he couldn't work ... and, I believe, putting acid in his eyes so he couldn't see," Henry testified.

Henry said she refused Schwartz's repeated offers and up to $3,500, but when her family met with financial difficulties, she decided to lead the doctor on.

"I led him to believe that [my husband] would do it," she told jurors. "I lied to him because we needed money."

Another prosecution witness, Stephanie Nagel, testified that the defendant asked her on a date at a federal courthouse where the two were required to submit urine samples because of pending cases — Schwartz for illegally prescribing pills, Nagel for forgery.

"He flirted. He hit on me. He asked me out a couple times," Nagel said. "But I was in a relationship, and he just wasn't my type."

The flirtation turned bizarre when Schwartz offered her $500 if she could recommend a person "who could take care of someone for him."

Though she never followed through on Schwartz's offer, she said she later told police about the incident after learning of Stidham's murder.

Carlos Ogas, a phlebotomist who worked at a laboratory where Schwartz also went to submit court-ordered urine samples, told jurors that Schwartz made a similar offer to him in a back room.

Several more witnesses whom Schwartz apparently asked to harm Stidham are expected to testify Friday afternoon and next week.

Court TV Extra is streaming it live on the Web.

E-mail | Print


 


Eye Doctor Murder Trial
Ariz. v. Schwartz


Watch the trial


May 3, 2006:
Defendant found guilty

April 27, 2006:
Jury deliberates

April 13, 2006:
Medical examiner admits error

April 5, 2006:
DNA not a definitive link, expert testifies

April 3, 2006:
Defense attacks state's timeline

March 28, 2006:
Possible DNA link on car radio?

March 23, 2006:
Jurors visit crime scene

March 22, 2006:
Defense calls for mistrial

March 17, 2006:
Claim: Man asked lover's husband to attack rival

March 16, 2006:
Doctor talked about killing rival, say witnesses

March 10, 2006:
Jury gets lesson in 'whacking'

March 9, 2006:
Doctor killed in car, witness says

March 8, 2006:
Opening statements

Case background




advertisement
 

 

Contact us
©2007 Turner Entertainment Digital Network, Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
CourtTV.com is a part of the Turner Entertainment New Media Network.
Terms & Privacy Guidelines

 
advertisement