Florida woman accused of stabbing deputy in neck

Posted at 7:08 AM, March 30, 2022 and last updated 3:13 PM, December 13, 2022

By Matt Papaycik, Ryan Hughes

FORT PIERCE, Fla. (WPTV) — The St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Office released dramatic body camera video Friday showing a deputy being stabbed in the neck by a distraught woman authorities said he was trying to help.


Deputies responded to a rollover crash in the 12500 block of South Indian River Drive around 11 p.m. Wednesday and found a vehicle unoccupied.

The sheriff’s office said Deputy Cody Colangelo, 22, located the driver, Leigha Michelle Day, 21, down an embankment near the crash scene.

Colangelo’s body camera video released Friday shows the deputy walking down a flight of steps toward Day, who’s pacing along a shoreline.

“What’s going on?” Colangelo asks.

“I don’t know,” Day responds, choking back tears.

“Were you just in a crash?” Colangelo says.

Day quickly begins to walk away.

Leigha Michelle Day, 21, seen on St. Lucie County Deputy Cody Colangelo’s body camera video on March 23, 2022. (St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Offica via WPTV)

“Ma’am, come up here,” Colangelo says. “Don’t walk away.”

Colangelo approaches Day, who’s visibly distraught in the video and crying uncontrollably.

“Walk upstairs, all right? Let’s get out of this water area,” Colangelo says.

“I don’t wanna. I’m scared,” Day responds.

Colangelo eventually convinces Day to walk up a flight of stairs to the road.

“Don’t run. Slowly walk,” says Colangelo, who’s seen walking behind Day in the video.

Day gets about halfway up the stairs before suddenly turning around and stabbing Colangelo in the neck. The deputy screams out, the blade nicking his carotid artery, authorities said.

Day ran off and Colangelo fired one shot at her, but missed.

Despite being stabbed and suffering a severe injury, Colangelo chased after Day while applying pressure to his wound, the sheriff’s office said.

Colangelo, who joined the St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Office in 2020, was able to radio other deputies for help. Authorities eventually found Day hiding down an embankment and took her into custody.

Colangelo was taken to HCA Florida Lawnwood Hospital, where he underwent a two-hour surgery during which doctors replaced part of the artery in his neck with one from his leg.

The St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Office said Friday afternoon that Colangelo is at home and resting comfortably.

“Usually, people don’t do well with that injury,” Dr. Christopher Binette, who operated on Colangelo, told WPTV.

Colangelo is being praised for using his training to save his life, applying pressure to his neck while chasing after Day and calling for backup.

Deputy Cody Colangelo in a department-issued photo from the St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Office. (St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Office via WPTV)

“Of all the things, that’s probably the thing that was the most important maneuver before he got here,” Binette said.

Binette said Colangelo is lucky, and had he been stabbed two to three inches lower, the outcome could have been much different.

“If the knife had a downward trajectory, very, very different story,” Binette said. “He probably wouldn’t have made it to the hospital.”

Colangelo as an incision on his neck, but the doctor said he should be healed in a few weeks.

Day, meanwhile, remains behind bars in the St. Lucie County Jail on a charge of premeditated first-degree attempted murder. Investigators believe she was under the influence of alcohol or drugs at the time of the stabbing.

The sheriff’s office said it’s unclear why Day suddenly attacked Colangelo as he tried to help her.

This story was originally published March 25 by WPTV in West Palm Beach, an E.W. Scripps Company.