Trial & Error Sundays

WV v. Andy McCauley: Teen Killed Murder Trial

Cpl. Luke Shambaugh, Deborah Clavette & Sgt. Andy O'Dell

Cpl. Luke Shambaugh, Deborah Clavette & Sgt. Andy O'Dell take the stand.

Trial Archives

14-WV v. McCauley: Cpl. Luke Shambaugh, Deborah Clavette & Sgt. Andy O'Dell

1-WV v. McCauley: Opening Statements

2-WV v. McCauley: Capt. Timothy Stapleton

3-WV v. McCauley: Chantel Oakley

4-WV v. McCauley: John Doe

5-WV v. McCauley: Donald Morgan

6-WV v. McCauley: Bobbie Golden

7-WV v. McCauley: Christopher McCauley

8-WV v. McCauley: Donna Walter & Johnnie Walter

9-WV v. McCauley: Denise Deaver & Brenda Lee

10-WV v. McCauley: Sgt. Janette See

11-WV v. McCauley: Det. Cpl. J.D. Luciano & Sgt. Johnathan Bowman

12-WV v. McCauley: Cpl. Fred Edwards

13-WV v. McCauley: Brandy Eggeman

14-WV v. McCauley: Cpl. Luke Shambaugh, Deborah Clavette & Sgt. Andy O'Dell

15-WV v. McCauley: Andy McCauley & Chantel Oakley Recording

16-WV v. McCauley: Sgt. Janette See & 1st Sgt. Dean Olack

17-WV v. McCauley: S.A. Ellen Duffy & Lt. Adam Albaugh

18-WV v. McCauley: Dr. Piotr Kubiczek

19-WV v. McCauley: 1st Sgt. Sean Wolfe

20-WV v. McCauley: Howard Ruark

21-WV v. McCauley: Law Enforcement Testimony

22-WV v. McCauley: Cpl. Fred Edwards

23-WV v. McCauley: David Miller

24-WV v. McCauley: Melissa Runyon

25-WV v. McCauley: Dominick Mongold & David Boober

26-WV v. McCauley: S.A. Ryan Burke

27-WV v. McCauley: Jane Doe

28-WV v. McCauley: Haydn Lacy

29-WV v. McCauley: Charge Conference

30-WV v. McCauley: Jury Instructions

31-WV v. McCauley: Prosecution Closing Argument

32-WV v. McCauley: Defense Closing Argument & Prosecution Rebuttal

Andy McCauley reacts as the jury's verdict is read in his murder trial

33-WV v. McCauley: Verdict

34-WV v. McCauley: Mercy Phase