Toby Madden was convicted of stabbing his longtime girlfriend 55 times at the couple's Ohio home in 2022, leading to her death. Victim Rachelle Brewsaugh had been stabbed in the chest, abdomen, head, back, knees, arms, shoulders, and hands.
McKayla Madden, the daughter of Toby Madden and his victim, Rachelle Brewsaugh shares memories of her mother and her strained relationship with her father. More
October 1, 2024
Julie Grant addresses Carly Gregg’s request for a new trial, Toby Madden's courtroom outbursts and other trending true crime cases. More
September 30, 2024
Toby Madden said, 'I'm the one that caused this tragedy,' as he was sentenced for murdering his longtime girlfriend, Rachelle Brewsaugh. More
September 27, 2024
Toby Madden heard the verdict and spoke at sentencing from a different room after repeated outbursts in court. More
September 27, 2024
As emotions run high, Julie Grant's top story analyzes what the defense should present and whether Toby Madden will testify. More
September 27, 2024
Toby Madden was banned from the courtroom after he began yelling at the jury about evidence in his case after the prosecutor spoke. More
September 27, 2024
Toby Madden's defense attorney told the jury that his client was covered in the victims blood because he had been doing CPR to save her. More
September 27, 2024
Prosecutor Michael Hon told the jury that Toby Madden said himself, 'I'm responsible for what happened' before his murder trial even began. More
September 27, 2024
Toby Madden speaks out in court, complaining about his defense attorney, Lucas Wilder, and the handling of his case. More
September 27, 2024
Rachelle Brewsaugh's friend, Tania Cook, told the jury that Toby Madden said he'd cut Brewsaugh's head off and place it in her mother's lap. More
September 26, 2024
Detective reviews close up images of the Swiss Army knife and blade attachments that were within the knife used to kill Rachelle Brewsaugh. More
September 25, 2024
As testimony resumes in his trial, Toby Madden’s emotional outbursts and his possible defense are the topics of discussion in Julie Grant’s top story. More
September 25, 2024
Rachelle Brewsaugh's daughter cries looking at autopsy photos of her mom with stab wounds so bad people could see intestines protruding. More
September 25, 2024
Toby Madden's elderly female ex-neighbor, Ann Mayers, reenacts the scream she heard from Madden's house and says he was strange and scary. More
September 24, 2024
Toby Madden sobs uncontrollably as a detective recalls arriving at the crime scene, seeing the victim's grave injuries, and rescue efforts. More
September 24, 2024
McKayla Madden, daughter of defendant Toby Madden and victim Rachelle Brewsaugh, was the first witness to take the stand in OH v. Toby Madden. More
September 23, 2024
Prosecutor delivers the State's open in the case against Toby Madden, who's accused of fatally stabbing girlfriend Rachelle Brewsaugh. More
September 23, 2024
Toby Madden broke down crying and sobbing before opening statements in the Stabbed 55 Times Murder Trial even began. More
September 23, 2024
