WV v. Chester Lilly: Deadly Neighborhood Feud

Mercy Phase

The jury hears arguments and testimony on the mercy phase for Chester Lilly, who was convicted of murdering his neighbor, Travis Peters. MORE

Trial Archives

15-WV v. Lilly: Mercy Phase

Chester Lilly sits in court

1-WV v. Lilly: Opening Statements

Woman testifies in court

2-WV v. Lilly: Emily Patrick & LaDonna Reid

Man testifies in court

3-WV v. Lilly: Adrienne Jones, Deion Daley & Dustin Tingler

Man testifies in court

4-WV v. Lilly: Keith Roberts

dark courtroom

5-WV v. Lilly: Dr. Jacquelyn Benjamin

Man testifies in court

6-WV v. Lilly: Det. Kyle Barnett

photo of victim

7-WV v. Lilly: Det. Kyle Barnett PT2

man testifies in court

8-WV v. Lilly: Det. Kyle Barnett PT3

man testifies in court

9-WV v. Lilly: Josh Haynes

Chester Lilly testifies in his murder trial

10-WV v. Lilly: Chester Lilly III

Judge addresses jury

11-WV v. Lilly: Jury Instructions

Chester Lilly in court

12-WV v. Lilly: Closing Arguments

Chester Lilly sits in court

13-WV v. Lilly: Jury Deliberations

attorneys and Chester Lilly stand in court

14-WV v. Lilly: Verdict

man speaks in court

15-WV v. Lilly: Mercy Phase

attorneys and Chester Lilly stand in court

16-WV v. Lilly: Mercy Phase Verdict