Skip to main content
Follow Us

‘Let’s settle it outside’: Judge scolds attorney for trying to start ‘fistfight’ in court

DALLAS, Ga. (Court TV) — A Georgia prosecutor invited opposing counsel to step outside and settle their dispute Tuesday morning after defense counsel accused him of lying to the jury.

“I don’t know what to say,” Judge Dean Bucci said after ordering both attorneys to stop talking.

Lacy Jolee Boles in court

Lacy Jolee Boles sits in court on Nov. 17, 2026. (Court TV)

Lacy Boles, 43, is standing trial on murder charges in the death of her husband, Daniel Akers, 36. Akers died after he was shot once in the head in the home he shared with his wife; prosecutors have accused Boles of killing her husband during an argument, but Boles contends Akers took his own life.

At the time of his death, Akers was on probation for a drug conviction and was facing the possibility of going to prison because he had not fulfilled the probation requirements, which included paying fines and doing community service. Bucci had previously ruled that the jury would not get to hear about the probation violations, but that changed Tuesday after Boles’ attorney accused prosecutors of eliciting misleading evidence from a witness.

On Monday, when one of the lead detectives in the case testified, prosecutors asked him whether Akers had met his probation requirements; the detective replied that he didn’t know. Standing in court on Tuesday, Boles’ attorney, Brian Steel, said the detective’s response was “outrageous” and a lie intentionally elicited by the prosecution. “This is outrageous conduct. It’s misconduct,” Steel said. “You are misinforming, misleading and obstructing justice to this jury by giving them the impression that really, maybe [Akers] wasn’t worried about prison.”

Listen: More from Court TV

Steel accused prosecutor Jason Treadaway of purposefully asking the detective the question to make the jury believe that Akers was in compliance with his probation and not at risk of going to prison. “I’m going to argue in closing argument that it was a sham, just like this whole trial,” Steel said. “This has to be corrected. This is a misstatement; a knowing misstatement of fact.”

Treadaway stood up, angry, and pointed toward Steel as he spoke.

Treadaway: Your Honor, I’m not going to dignify this man for his statements by defending my ethical integrity in this process or in this courtroom. If he wants to question that, let’s settle it outside by the Christmas tree in front of the courthouse.
Bucci: That’s out of line. Inviting opposing counsel to a fistfight in front of the courthouse is out of line, and you know that.
Treadaway: So, is it out of line for him to call me a liar, stating that I have introduced this evidence purposefully and willfully to mislead a jury? That I’m a liar? He called me a liar in open court.
Bucci: I don’t think you’re a liar at all. You’ve practiced in front of me for a long time. I don’t think you’re a liar, but you can’t call opposing counsel out to fight in front of the courthouse.
Treadaway: I said we’d settle it on our own.
Bucci: You know what that means.

Attorney stands with hand outstretched in court

Prosecutor Jason Treadaway motions to defense attorney Brian Steel during arguments outside the jury’s presence on Nov. 17, 2026. (Court TV)

Treadaway insisted that Steel mischaracterized how he phrased the question, which asked whether the detective knew whether Akers had tried to comply with the terms of his probation. “This is just a thinly veiled attempt to drag [Akers’] name through the mud,” Treadaway said. “To impugn the character of a victim who’s no longer able to defend himself or his character.”

Bucci ultimately agreed with Steel that prosecutors had opened the door for the jury to hear more about Akers’ criminal record and his failure to comply with the terms of his probation.

By the time the jury was brought into the courtroom, tempers had cooled. “As you know, I wear my emotions on my sleeve; I take my job and my responsibilities seriously,” Treadaway said. “I apologize for my comment to [Steel] and mostly to this honorable court. I did not mean to impugn the dignity of this honorable court. But hopefully, this court appreciates the seriousness with which I take this, as well as Mr. Steel, and when someone calls me a liar in open court on the record, it rubs me the wrong way. But I apologize to this court.”