Skip to main content
Follow Us

Pro se plastic surgeon tries to disqualify judge moments before he’s sentenced to death

CLEARWATER, Fla. (Court TV) — A plastic surgeon who represented himself on murder charges failed in a last-ditch effort to remove the judge from his case before that same judge sentenced him to death.

Tomasz Kosowski sits in court

Tomasz Kosowski appears in court for sentencing on Nov. 20, 2026. (Court TV)

Tomasz Kosowski, 47, was convicted of first-degree murder in the presumed death of attorney Steven Cozzi, 41, whose body has never been found. Kosowski was embroiled in a lawsuit with several of Cozzi’s clients at the time of the victim’s March 2023 disappearance.

At his trial, prosecutors said that Kosowski attacked Cozzi in the bathroom of his law firm and then used a wagon to wheel the body out of the building before putting it in the back of a pickup truck. Prosecutors said Kosowski ultimately disposed of Cozzi’s body in a dumpster. Despite extensive searches of a nearby landfill, his remains were never found.

On Friday, Kosowski returned to court for the final phase of his sentencing, which was drawn out over several hearings because prosecutors were seeking the death penalty. While Kosowski refused the assistance of an attorney and declined to present any mitigating evidence, Judge Joseph Bulone appointed special counsel to act as a third party and present mitigating evidence on the defendant’s behalf.

As soon as Friday’s hearing began, it was quickly delayed after Kosowski presented a written motion to disqualify Bulone. Bulone accepted the document and left the room to read it. He returned about 20 minutes later with a written order, which he handed to Kosowski, and proceeded directly to sentencing.

Bulone said that after weighing all of the testimony and evidence, he found that prosecutors had proven two aggravating factors in Cozzi’s murder and that special counsel had proved one statutory mitigating circumstance and five non-statutory mitigating circumstances for Kosowski. Weighing those facts, Bulone said, he found “the defendant has forfeited his right to live” and sentenced him to death at the discretion of the Florida Department of Corrections.

Listen: More from Court TV

Bulone appointed a public defender for appellate purposes; before Kosowski left the courtroom, he handed a folder of papers to a woman who met with him at the counsel table.