Skip to main content
Follow Us

‘You used her to fulfill your sick fantasies’: Man gets 2 life sentences for killing woman he met on fetish website

OCALA, Fla. (Court TV) — A Florida man sat silently as he was sentenced to two consecutive life terms for kidnapping and murdering a woman he met on a fetish website.

A jury deliberated for about an hour before finding Dwain Hall, 54, guilty of first-degree murder and kidnapping in the death of Sonia Exelby, 33.

Dwain Hall in court

Dwain Hall sits in court on Nov. 20, 2026. (Court TV)

Exelby first met Hall on the now-defunct website motherless.com, where Hall had the username “AlphaSadist.” Exelby, who lived in the United Kingdom, had a history of mental health struggles. Prosecutors said that Hall spent two years online manipulating and grooming Exelby until she decided to get on a plane and come to Florida. “Think about what he must have said to her over those two years,” prosecutor Amy Beth Berndt said in her closing argument to the jury on Friday. “How did he manipulate her to get her to leave home and travel thousands of miles to come here? What made her think that she would be successful with him in her attempt to commit suicide by proxy?”

Listen: More from Court TV

Evidence presented at Hall’s trial showed that Exelby had a history of depression and suicide attempts; prosecutors conceded she may have asked the defendant for help killing herself, but said that would not make it legal. Berndt also said evidence, including a letter Exelby wrote to herself while on the plane to the United States, indicated she regretted leaving home and was scared. “Sonia Exelby’s consent is not a defense to the crime of first-degree murder,” Berndt said. “She cannot consent to that. He can’t do that. I think we proved to you she changed her mind, but again, even if you don’t believe that, this man does not have the right to kill her, even if she wants to die.”

Hall’s attorney, Junior Barrett, suggested that Exelby had taken her own life and stabbed herself four times. He said Hall may have given her access to the knife and then failed to get her medical care. “But the fact that he might not have helped her or stopped her from killing herself does not make him a murderer,” he said. “She knew what she wanted. When he wouldn’t do it, she did. She didn’t want to go back home; she didn’t want to live.”

“He said that maybe the defendant was careless with the knife. I think that he’s trying to imply that she grabbed the knife and then stabbed herself somehow,” Berndt countered. “Why’d he buy a tarp then? If this was just some spontaneous thing, why is he buying a tarp before he goes to the burial site?”

After the jury returned its verdict, Judge Timothy McCourt immediately began sentencing proceedings. He allowed Exelby’s four siblings to take the podium to address the gallery as they delivered their victim impact statements.

“This tragedy has changed us forever, but because of the truth and the accountability reached in this courtroom today, we can finally begin to heal,” one of her brothers said.

Her other brother addressed the defendant directly:

Dwain, you pretended to care for Sonia. You didn’t at all. You used her to fulfill your sick fantasies. You had her life in your hands. You had the opportunity to save her. But instead, you preyed on her vulnerabilities and you took her from us. There will never be any forgiveness coming to you behind bars.

Hall declined to speak when offered the opportunity.

McCourt sentenced Hall to two consecutive life terms, with 400 days’ credit for time served on the first sentence. Hall asked if he could keep Barrett as his attorney during the appellate process, but McCourt warned him that was unlikely.