COLUMBUS, Ohio (Court TV) — A convicted killer erupted in court Thursday before her scheduled sentencing, calling her attorney the “Antichrist” and saying she wanted to fire him.

Pammy Maye is held in her seat by deputies during sentencing on Nov. 19, 2026. (Court TV)
Pammy Maye, 51, was convicted of tampering with evidence and abuse of a corpse in the death of 5-year-old Darnell Taylor, the child she and her husband had taken custody of. Prosecutors said at Maye’s trial that she had been upset with the child for eating peanut butter and crackers in his room in the hours before she suffocated him with a plastic bag.
After Darnell’s death, Maye admitted to taking the child’s body and leaving it in a sewer in the neighborhood where her parents had once lived. Then, she returned home and confessed what she had done to her husband, who immediately called 911.
At her trial, Maye’s attorney, Samuel Shamansky, conceded that his client had killed the victim but argued that she was severely mentally ill and not criminally responsible for her behavior.
On Nov. 19, Maye returned to court for her sentencing. Just as Judge Mark Serrott warned the courtroom to maintain decorum during the hearing, the defendant stood at her seat and began shouting: “You are the Antichrist! Yes, you are!”
Serrott ordered Maye to sit, and deputies held her in her chair. Shamansky tried to calm his client further, but she continued to yell at him, saying, “No! I don’t want your help. You’re the Antichrist.” At that point, Maye was removed from the courtroom.
Several minutes later, Maye was brought back into court, and the hearing resumed with Shamansky telling Serrott that he was withdrawing from the case. “Ms. Maye has made allegations about the manner in which I’ve represented her, and at this juncture she no longer desires my assistance,” he said.
When Serrott asked Maye why she no longer wanted Shamansky as her attorney, Maye said, “Because he represented me like he was a prosecutor instead of defending me, and plus everything that was in the footage about me was edited.”
Serrott: Why do you think he acted like a prosecutor?
Maye: He already said I was guilty, guilty, guilty and then when he was talking to the jury, he was like —
Serrott: What do you mean he said you were guilty guilty? You confessed to the crime, ma’am —
Maye: I know that.
Serrott: Don’t interrupt me. I get to interrupt you.
Serrott warned Maye to keep Shamansky on her team. “I saw him fight hard for your defense,” he said. “I saw him make one of the best closing arguments I’ve ever seen with nothing really to work with.”
Maye then stood and began to ramble about “God’s wrath” and claimed that she had previously been “possessed by demons” before Jesus came to visit her a month ago.
The hearing continued, with Shamansky remaining next to Maye at the counsel table. The defendant cried as she listened to Darnell’s family deliver victim impact statements, remembering a happy and loving boy.
“I was very selfish,” Maye said when she was given another chance to speak. “He was a loving child. He was a perfect child.”
Serrott said he was “haunted” by a photo of Darnell after his death as he sentenced Maye to 29 years to life in prison. She will be eligible for parole when she is 80.
