Skip to main content
Follow Us

Man told detectives he helped victim ‘get what she wanted’ after killing her and burying her body: Prosecutors

OCALA, Fla. (Court TV) — Prosecutors said that a man accused of killing a woman he met on a fetish website told detectives that he helped the victim “get what she wanted.”

Dwain Hall, 54, is charged with first-degree murder and kidnapping in the death of Sonia Exelby, 33. In his opening statement to the jury on Tuesday, Hall’s attorney asked the panel simply to listen to all the witnesses before determining what happened.

Dwain Hall sits in court

Dwain Hall sits in court on Nov. 17, 2026. (Court TV)

Prosecutors said that Exelby’s death was the culmination of what they described as years of grooming and manipulation that began when the two met online on a now-defunct website. The website, motherless.com, was known for allowing users to upload pornographic material that often included violence toward women or illegal materials depicting children.

Hall’s username on the website was “AlphaSadist,” a fact prosecutor Amy Beth Berndt highlighted for the jury in her opening statement. “[Exelby] was brutally murdered by a predator,” Berndt said. “A man who calls himself ‘AlphaSadist.’ A man who was sexually aroused by the rape and torture of women. That man is the defendant, Dwain Hall.”

Listen: More from Court TV

Berndt described Exelby as a survivor of a traumatic childhood who continued to suffer from severe mental illness. Exelby’s fiance, the first witness to testify on Tuesday, said that the victim had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder and had suffered from eating disorders as well as other self-harming behavior. But in the days and weeks before her death, Exelby’s fiance said, she had seemed better.

On Oct. 10, 2025, Exelby lied to her fiance and told him that she was going to visit her sister. Instead, she got on a plane and traveled to Gainesville, Florida. When she didn’t return home two days later as planned, Exelby’s fiance reached out to the police and then logged on to her computer, where he found a disturbing email the victim had sent to herself after getting on the plane to the United States. “I’ve never hurt so much. I’m trying so hard not to have a panic attack,” the message said. “As soon as the wheels left the ground, I wished I was home, but I can’t get off the plane and it’s moving.”

Investigators in the United Kingdom alerted detectives in Marion County, Florida, after determining that Exelby had bought a ticket and booked an Airbnb there. Detectives in Florida linked Exelby to Hall after his business tried to run her credit card for a $1,200 charge that was declined.

In interviews with investigators, Hall initially denied knowing Exelby. He recanted that story after four hours of questioning and admitted that he had had sex with the victim after meeting her online. He denied killing her, however, telling investigators he helped her “get what she wanted.”

Berndt said that when investigators searched the rented Airbnb, they found a receipt in the trash from a Walmart trip made before Exelby’s plane landed. Video from the store showed Hall purchasing gun oil, rope, a shovel and deodorant, Berndt said.

Detectives who looked at Hall’s cellphone records noticed that he had spent the morning of Oct. 12 in the woods; a search of the area revealed Exelby’s body in a shallow grave. Berndt said that she was nude except for her bra and sandals and had the flowered dress she had worn on the plane draped over her.

If you or someone you know is in crisis in the United States, call or text the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988.