WV v. Chester Lilly: Deadly Neighborhood Feud

Mercy Phase Verdict

The jury reaches a verdict in the mercy phase for Chester Lilly, after previously finding him guilty of murdering his neighbor, Travis Peters. MORE

Trial Archives

16-WV v. Lilly: Mercy Phase Verdict

Chester Lilly sits in court

1-WV v. Lilly: Opening Statements

Woman testifies in court

2-WV v. Lilly: Emily Patrick & LaDonna Reid

Man testifies in court

3-WV v. Lilly: Adrienne Jones, Deion Daley & Dustin Tingler

Man testifies in court

4-WV v. Lilly: Keith Roberts

dark courtroom

5-WV v. Lilly: Dr. Jacquelyn Benjamin

Man testifies in court

6-WV v. Lilly: Det. Kyle Barnett

photo of victim

7-WV v. Lilly: Det. Kyle Barnett PT2

man testifies in court

8-WV v. Lilly: Det. Kyle Barnett PT3

man testifies in court

9-WV v. Lilly: Josh Haynes

Chester Lilly testifies in his murder trial

10-WV v. Lilly: Chester Lilly III

Judge addresses jury

11-WV v. Lilly: Jury Instructions

Chester Lilly in court

12-WV v. Lilly: Closing Arguments

Chester Lilly sits in court

13-WV v. Lilly: Jury Deliberations

attorneys and Chester Lilly stand in court

14-WV v. Lilly: Verdict

man speaks in court

15-WV v. Lilly: Mercy Phase

attorneys and Chester Lilly stand in court

16-WV v. Lilly: Mercy Phase Verdict