Police release video of Jesse Butler’s arrest after controversial plea deal

Posted at 1:00 PM, November 9, 2025 and last updated 11:41 AM, December 11, 2025

STILLWATER, Okla. (Scripps News Tulsa) — Stillwater police released the body camera footage of the arrest of Jesse Butler for multiple counts of rape-related charges.

blurred face of teen as he's arrested

Bodycamera footage showed Jesse Butler as he was arrested on multiple rape-related charges. (Stillwater Police Dept. via Scripps News Tulsa)

Scripps News is bluring his face due to him being a minor at the time of his arrest.

Butler pleaded no-contest to 10 rape-related charges and one charge of violating a protective order. He was given a 78-year sentence that would’ve been around 10 years in prison if served concurrently.

MORE | Victim’s lawyer files new motion in Jesse Butler rape case

However, a deal made between the prosecution and defense resulted in no jail time, but counseling instead. Butler’s father is a former football director at Oklahoma State University, leaving some to believe his connections led to a lighter sentence.

The case garnered national attention and the attention of Oklahoma lawmaker Justin JJ Humphrey.

In late October, Stillwater police issued a statement saying they were investigating calls made to Stillwater Public Schools about the case.

This story was originally written by Jennifer Maupin for Scripps News Tulsa, an E.W. Scripps Company.

More Crime & Trial News

Related Articles: