Jeffrey Spence is accused of plotting with his wife, Karen, and daughter, Caitlin, to rob and murder Kirby Carpenter, who shared a child with Caitlin.
After a mistrial is declared in Jeffrey Spence's trial, guest host Julia Jenaé questions whether he killed Kirby Carpenter. More
September 30, 2025
After the judge in MS v. Jeffrey Spence declared a mistrial, Kirby Carpenter's mom passed out. Paramedics were called, thankfully she's OK. More
September 29, 2025
After deliberating for about 4.5 hours, jurors in Mississippi v. Jeffrey Spence revealed they're deadlocked 6 to 6. A mistrial was declared. More
September 29, 2025
The Mississippi jury deliberating the fate of Jeffrey Spence sent a note telling the judge they're unable to reach a unanimous decision. More
September 29, 2025
David Hill presents closings saying the state has no 'hard proof' of Jeffrey Spence's guilt and they're 'leaving a lot out' of the timeline. More
September 29, 2025
UPDATE: Jeff Spence is charged with the murder of Kirby Carpenter, his daughter's boyfriend, who was allegedly killed during a robbery. More
September 29, 2025
Thad James Mueller presents the State's closings, saying 'there's a lot of evidence in this case... everything points to Jeff Spence.' More
September 29, 2025
Jeffrey Spence's daughter, Carolyn Aguayo, took the stand and delivered scathing testimony about her father and his behavior. More
September 29, 2025
What impact will the testimony of Caitlin and Carolyn Spencer, Jeffrey Spencer's daughters, have on the jury in his murder trial? More
September 29, 2025
Carolyn Aguayo testified about years of conflict with her father Jeffrey Spence, who is on trial for murdering Kirby Carpenter. More
September 27, 2025
Carolyn Aguayo, defendant Jeffrey Spence's daughter said 'I saw an anger and a violence in his eyes I had never seen before.' More
September 26, 2025
Carolyn Aguayo, Jeffrey Spence's daughter, told the jury, 'When you get out of a criminal family, you have to watch your back.' More
September 26, 2025
Caitlin Spence took the stand to testify against her father after pleading guilty to her role in Kirby Carpenter's murder. More
September 26, 2025
Caitlin Spence detailed the days surrounding the death of her boyfriend, Kirby Carpenter, whom her dad, Jeffrey Spence, is accused of killing. More
September 26, 2025
Caitlin Spence, who is Jeffrey Spence's daughter and was Kirby Carpenter's girlfriend, testified that her dad confessed to killing Carpenter. More
September 25, 2025
Brad Johnson said he found jewelry, gold, over $38K in cash and more than $8K in counterfeit money in Jeffrey Spence's safe deposit boxes. More
September 25, 2025
Jeffrey Spence allegedly plotted with his wife, Karen Spence and their daughter, Caitlin Spence to kill Caitlin's boyfriend, Kirby Carpenter. More
September 24, 2025
Kirby Carpenter's lawyer recalled securing assets and handling disputes over missing valuables while handling the $1.5 million estate. More
September 24, 2025
Investigator Chris McAllister testifies as the court views crime scene photos where Jeffrey Spence is accused of killing Kirby Carpenter. More
September 24, 2025
In a 911 call played for the jury, the dispatcher asks a distraught Caitlin Spence, 'Are you trying to say he passed away?' More
September 24, 2025
Prosecutors say Jeffrey Spence was motivated by money and greed to murder Kirby Carpenter. The defense claims he wasn't even in the state. More
September 24, 2025
