Alleged hitman guilty of second-degree murder in bludgeoning death of Florida doctor

November 15, 2019

BY COURT TV STAFF

UPDATED 11/15/19: A sentencing hearing for alleged hitman Jimmy Rodgers has been rescheduled to December 12 at 1:30 pm ET. The hearing was originally scheduled for November 18, but that date would have interfered with the Mark Sievers’ trial that’s in the middle of jury selection.

The Jimmy Rodgers trial continued on Monday, October 14, 2019, for day 3 of testimony at the Lee County Justice Center in Fort Myers. (COURT TV)

Rodgers was found not guilty of first-degree murder and conspiracy. He’s facing life in prison for the death of 46-year-old Teresa Sievers, who was bludgeoned to death by a hammer in her Bonita Springs home in 2015.

Prosecutors say Mark Sievers planned his wife’s murder with the help of his longtime friend, Curtis Wright. Wright allegedly traveled to Missouri to hire Rodgers as a hitman and brought him back to Southwest Florida to carry out the heinous act.

 

>>ORIGINAL STORY
UPDATED 10/23/19: A jury found alleged hitman Jimmy Rodgers guilty of second-degree murder and trespassing. Rodgers was found not guilty of first-degree murder and conspiracy. He’s now facing life in prison.
ORIGINAL STORY 10/1/19:

Two men are facing the death penalty in the gruesome murder of a beloved holistic doctor in South Florida.

 

>>HITMAN MURDER TRIAL RECENT COVERAGE

46-year-old Teresa Sievers was bludgeoned to death at her Bonita Springs home on June 28, 2015, after returning home alone from a trip to Connecticut. Her body, which reportedly sustained seventeen blunt force trauma blows, was found the next day.

Investigators had no suspects until they received a tip via phone call on July 9. That tip led to the arrests of Jimmy Ray Rodgers and a longtime friend of Teresa’s husband, Curtis Wright. Despite a cloud of suspicion, Teresa’s husband lived as a free man until February 26, 2016.

Mark Sievers (left) and Jimmy Rodgers (right) Courtesy of Lee County S.O.

Prosecutors say Mark Sievers planned his wife’s murder with the help of Wright, who allegedly traveled to Missouri to hire Rodgers as a hitman and brought him back to Southwest Florida. Although investigators believe Rodgers killed Teresa, Mark and Wright are accused of orchestrating the attack.

Detectives still aren’t clear on Mark’s alleged motive. Text messages and phone records between the couple reportedly show a roller coaster marriage filled with intense affection, contempt and “swinging,” which included flirtation between Teresa and Wright. Friends of the couple reportedly told investigators their marriage was rocky, and Mark may have feared he would lose his daughters in a divorce. Multi-million-dollar life insurance policies taken out on Teresa also suggest a financial motive.

Mark is charged with first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder. Rodgers is charged with first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder and first-degree burglary while armed. Both defendants are facing the death penalty. Wright, who will testify as a key witness, took a 25-year plea deal for his role.

TIMELINE:

Mark and Teresa Siever’s Bonita Springs home. Courtesy of WFTX

2015

  • April 30: Mark and Wright allegedly begin to plot Teresa’s death.
  • June 28-29: Teresa’s body found in her Bonita Springs home.
  • July 9: Investigators receive a tip about Teresa’s killers.
  • August 25: Jimmy Ray Rodgers arrested.
  • August 27: Curtis Wright arrested.

2016

  • February 25-26: Wright accepts a plea deal. Mark arrested and charged with second-degree murder.
  • May 4: Grand jury indicts Rodgers and Mark.
  • May 5: While in custody, Mark is served with a warrant for first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder.
  • June 22: Prosecutors file notice of intent to seek the death penalty against Rodgers and Mark.

2019

  • August 19: Judge Bruce Kyle grants Defense motion to have Rodgers and Mark tried separately.
  • October 1: Jury selection begins in the trials of FL v. Sievers and FL v. Rodgers.
  • October 23: A jury finds Jimmy Rodgers guilty of second-degree murder and trespass. Rodgers is found not guilty of first-degree murder and conspiracy. He faces life in prison.
MORE NEWS