Devon Arthurs takes plea deal in 2017 slayings of Florida roommates

Posted at 1:41 PM, May 8, 2023 and last updated 1:41 PM, May 8, 2023

TAMPA, Fla. (Scripps News Tampa) — Just moments before potential jurors filled the courtroom, Devon Arthurs’ attorney announced he would be accepting a plea deal instead of going to trial, abruptly avoiding the start of a murder trial in which Arthurs had planned to use the insanity defense, according to court records.

Devon Arthurs mugshot

FILE – This photo provided by the Tampa, Fla., Police Department on May 20, 2017, shows Devon Arthurs. Arthurs pleaded guilty Monday, May 8, 2023, to fatally shooting his two Florida roommates in 2017, abruptly avoiding the start of a murder trial in which he had planned to use the insanity defense, according to court records. (Tampa Police Department via AP, File)

Arthurs, 24, acknowledged killing two of his roommates, Jeremy Himmelman, 18, and Andrew Oneschuk, 22, on May 19, 2017. Arthurs then went to a nearby smoke shop, where he held an employee and two shoppers hostage until the police arrived.

He pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder and will serve a 45-year prison sentence plus 15 years probation. The plea deal with prosecutors means Arthur will not face a possible life sentence.

Arthurs told police after his arrest that all three had been part of a small, mostly online neo-Nazi group called the Atomwaffen Division and that he shot the pair with an assault-style rifle because they ridiculed his conversion to Islam. He spoke in court, saying he promises to live his life-fighting extremist hate groups and helping people battling addiction.

According to court documents, when a responding officer asked Arthurs if anyone was hurt, Arthurs stated, “The people in the apartment, but they aren’t hurt. They’re dead.”

The records indicate he told the officers they were “definitely dead” and directed officers to his front door at The Hamptons at Tampa Palms Apartments.

Inside the apartment the men shared, authorities said they found guns, ammunition and bomb-making material, along with a framed picture of Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh on a bedroom dresser. Atomwaffen is German for “nuclear weapons.”

A third roommate and Atomwaffen co-founder, Brandon Russell, was not home when the slayings happened but found the bodies when he returned from duties with the National Guard, investigators said. Russell pleaded guilty in September 2017 to federal charges of possessing illegal firearms and a destructive device, as well as storing explosives illegally.

The bomb-making materials — including the highly explosive substance HMTD, several pounds of ammonium nitrate and homemade fuses — were discovered during the murder investigation. Arthurs told police the group planned terrorist attacks, possibly against nuclear plants.

“I prevented the deaths of a lot of people,” Arthurs said in a rambling statement after his arrest. Asked why his roommates would plan such an attack, he responded, “Because they want to build a Fourth Reich.”

Devon Arthurs police interview

This photo from video provided by the Tampa Police Department shows Devon Arthurs. (Tampa Police via WFTS)

Russell was sentenced to five years in prison on the weapons and bomb charges. After his release, he was charged in a new case earlier this year with plotting with a Maryland woman to attack Baltimore’s power grid in an attempt to stir racial unrest. Prosecutors said that plan was to target five substations situated in a ring around the majority-Black city. No attack took place.

Russell and his co-defendant, Sarah Beth Clendaniel, have both pleaded not guilty in Maryland federal court and are awaiting trial.

As for Arthurs, his case was delayed several times while he received mental treatment after being declared incompetent to stand trial in 2018 and again in 2020. Finally, in June 2022, a Hillsborough County judge determined Arthurs had restored his mental capacity sufficiently to stand trial.

“I feel I can be an advocate against extremism,” Arthurs said in court. “I’d like to take this moment to tell the world to stay away from extremist groups. … I’m very sorry for everyone that was involved. I’m very sorry for everything that has happened.”

This story was originally published by WFTS in Tampa Bay, an E.W. Scripps Company.