|
Death penalty foes say McVeigh execution becoming pageant
WASHINGTON (AP) Permitting a closed-circuit broadcast of
Timothy McVeigh's execution makes the event a "death pageant"
that could trigger a backlash against capital punishment, execution
opponents said.
Supporters of the death penalty expect just the opposite, that
the unapologetic Oklahoma City bomber's punishment will deepen
already strong public sentiment for executions.
McVeigh's execution will be shown by a remote broadcast to more
than 200 survivors and victims' relatives. Though infrequent, a few
states allow broadcasts like Attorney General John Ashcroft ordered
Thursday.
But the execution will not be publicly broadcast, just
transmitted to Oklahoma where survivors and victims can watch. It
also will not be taped.
The more fanfare over the May 16 execution at a federal
penitentiary in Terre Haute, Ind., the better for the anti-death
penalty movement, execution opponent Lance Lindsey said.
"There will be a growing revulsion" caused by
publicity-seekers and media attention, said Lindsey, executive
director of Death Penalty Focus in San Francisco. "This kind of
death pageant ... is just completely and profoundly sad."
0 About two-thirds of Americans polled this year said they support
the death penalty for murderers.
"If anything, I believe more people who were on the fence about
executions will move to" support it, said Dianne Clements,
president of Justice For All, a Texas-based victims' rights group.
McVeigh was convicted two years after the April 19, 1995,
federal building bombing that killed 168 people and injured
hundreds. He is set to become the first federal inmate executed
since 1963.
"Does punishing him make him a martyr? No," Clements said.
Ashcroft ordered the broadcast after meeting with some family
members who said viewing the execution would help the grieving
process. There is limited seating at the Indiana facility.
"I hope they do not become re-victimized again and become
somebody's punching bag, though I'm sure they will," Clements
said. "They'll be called everything from blood thirsty and
vengeful to ghoulish. That's not fair."
The Rev. Carroll Pickett, a former chaplain to Texas death row
inmates, said the broadcast, closed-circuit though it may be, plays
into the hands of McVeigh, who suggested that he would like his
death broadcast nationally.
"He wants the show," said Pickett. "He's asked for it and he
got it."
Only small groups of witnesses have been allowed at most of the
706 executions in the United States since 1976. Arkansas, Illinois
and Tennessee are among states that allow closed-circuit broadcasts
to give victims' families privacy and permit more people to watch.
"I don't think we should have this as a general thing. This is
an unprecedented case," said Jane Alexander, a founder of Citizens
Against Homicide in California, who wanted the victims to be
allowed to watch. "If this gives them any kind of solace or
closure, I think it's proper."
Alexander said she expects no backlash against the death penalty
and no calls for nationally televised executions. Ashcroft, in
announcing his decision, said the broadcast may help the group
"close this chapter on their lives."
"As difficult as this case is, it will contribute to furthering
the national discussion," predicted Marc Mauer, assistant director
of The Sentencing Project, a criminal justice policy group in
Washington.
Death penalty opponents will be allowed to protest McVeigh's
death on prison grounds. Not all of them agree that McVeigh, who
can make a statement before his death, helps the anti-execution
cause.
"It isn't a case that's going to change people's minds," said
Allyson Collins, a senior researcher in Washington with the Human
Rights Watch.
|