Judge picks Allen County for jury selection in Delphi murders trial

Posted at 6:37 AM, January 25, 2023 and last updated 4:03 PM, July 7, 2023

Photo Credit: WRTV

Days before the defense and prosecution reached an agreement between two northern Indiana counties, the judge issued an order stipulating jurors will be picked out of Allen County, which includes the city of Fort Wayne, roughly 100 miles from Delphi.

Later this year, a jury will hear a case regarding Richard Matthew Allen, 50, who was charged in October with two counts of murder in the 2017 killings of Liberty German, 14, and Abigail Williams, 13.

Allen lived and worked in Delphi, the girls’ hometown of about 3,000 people, which is part of Carroll County. Delphi is located around 60 miles northwest of Indianapolis. Allen County has more than 388,000 residents.

Judge Fran Gull, also from Allen County, was assigned to the case after the judge for Carroll County recused himself last year.

At a hearing earlier this month, Allen’s lawyers and the county prosecutor agreed the jury should come from a different location after defense attorneys in November requested the trial location be moved from Carroll County because of intense public scrutiny and media attention surrounding the case.

Gull said in the hearing that the trial should be conducted in Carroll County because friends and family members of the parties are situated in Delphi but that a jury should be selected elsewhere. Drawing from a county larger than Carroll County, which has about 20,000 residents, would be a benefit to assembling an impartial jury pool, Allen’s lawyers argued.

RELATED: Parties agree to possible locations of jurors in Delphi murders trial

When the trial occurs, those jurors will be transported from Allen County to Carroll County for the proceedings, which are scheduled for March but unlikely to occur before the fall, Gull said at the hearing.

A bail hearing for Allen is scheduled for Feb. 17.


Arleigh Rodgers, a corps member for the Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative Associated Press, and James Howell Jr. of WRTV in Indianapolis, an E.W. Scripps company, contributed to this report.