Shelby Nealy Faces Death Penalty for Killing Wife's Family

Sentencing hearing underway for Shelby Nealy, who pleaded guilty to killing his in-laws after they became suspicious that he'd killed his ex-wife, Jamie Ivancic. A jury must decide if he should be sentenced to death or life without parole. (7/17/25) MORE

Killer Spouses, Murder & Mayhem

Latest Videos

Judy Church VIS

‘Sleepless Nights & Grief Beyond Explanation’: Victim’s Sister’s Impact Statement

Judy Church verdict

Resentful Girlfriend Convicted of Poisoning Cheating Boyfriend

Judy Church-Commonwealth's closings

Extreme 'Atrocity and Cruelty': Commonwealth Says Judy Church Poisoned Lover

Judy Church's defense's closings

Judy Church ‘Too Smart' to Leave Poisoned Powerade in Boyfriend Murder Trial: Defense

Judy Church trial

Autopsy Horror: Leroy Fowler's Kidney Crystals Point to Antifreeze Poisoning

John Heywood Jr.

Judy Church Said 'If He Ever Cheats, I'll Poison Him': Victim’s Cousin

Judy Church interrogation

Accused Killer Girlfriend: Boyfriend Said, ‘I’m Gonna Die, You Know That, Don’t You?’

Judy Church trial

Victim Warned ‘Stepson’ His Girlfriend Was Allegedly Poisoning Him

Barbara Randall

Accused Killer Girlfriend Nicknamed 'Grandma' By Victim's Other Lover

Leroy Fowler

Accused Killer Girlfriend Records Boyfriend As He Writhes in Pain

Judy Church's voodoo doll

Accused Killer Girlfriend Had Voodoo Dolls of Victim's Girlfriend: Witness

Judy Church trial

Accused Killer Girlfriend's 911 Call: 'My Boyfriend Must Have Ingested Something'

MORE VIDEOS